Monday, November 16, 2026
52 °
Clear
Log in Subscribe

Plan Commission advances amendment to groundwater protection

Posted

STEVENS POINT — The Plan Commission voted unanimously to advance a zoning ordinance amendment allowing city officials to consider groundwater and wellhead protection rules from neighboring municipalities when evaluating development proposals. The proposed amendment would have allowed the City of Stevens Point to reject the Kwik Trip proposal that drew community concern due to the gas stations’ close proximity to the village of Whiting’s groundwater supply. 

The proposed change to Chapter 23 of the Revised Municipal Code marks a shift in regional land-use oversight, granting the Stevens Point Common Council discretionary authority to weigh adjacent communities' wellhead protection overlays during local zoning reviews.

The amendment was directly prompted by recent municipal friction over a proposed Kwik Trip gas station near the boundary of the Village of Whiting.

The Kwik Trip, currently under construction, near the intersection of Hoover Road and County Highway HH is considered to be within the city of Stevens Point, but its’ close proximity to the village of Whiting’s groundwater supply drew concern from Whiting officials. In Feb., Officials from the Village of Whiting urged the Stevens Point Common Council to expand their groundwater protection practices. Ultimately, in Feb. the Stevens Point Common Council approved the construction of the Kwik Trip. 

Under the current framework, city officials lacked clear statutory mechanisms to deny commercial development solely based on a neighboring town's wellhead protection map.

City Utilities Director Joel Lemke told commissioners the new language establishes an intentional legal bridge between bordering communities without imposing mandatory enforcement obligations on the city.

"This gives city Stevens Point the ability, but not the obligation, to act on an official request." Lemke said. 

City Attorney Andrew Beveridge underscored legal vulnerabilities that surfaced during earlier debates over the gas station. Without explicit ordinance text, the city relied on generalized "public welfare" provisions—an argument Beveridge cautioned rarely survives judicial review when restricting private property rights.

"If this language would have been present, I would have been confident to advise the council that they could reject it on that basis. Without that, I was not confident to make that recommendation." Beveridge said.

Beveridge explained the measure allows the city to "bootstrap onto their mapping" by referencing adjacent geographic surveys while enforcing Stevens Point's own zoning regulations.

During deliberations, Commissioner Jeff Schuler pressed the legal limits of cross-border restrictions, cautioning against the appearance of arbitrary enforcement. Calling the Kwik Trip debate a "non-hypothetical hypothetical," Schuler questioned how the city could legally defend declaring a land use prohibited inside city limits based on outside rules.

"What's the mechanism for the city to enforce someone else's regulations on a piece of property in the city?" Schuler asked.

Beveridge responded that municipal zoning derives from broad police powers, and codifying explicit legislative standards provides a strong legal defense.

"It's a heck of a lot better to show up in the courtroom with really strong arguments on your side than it is to show up having to try to invent something out of nothing," Beveridge said.

Public testimony focused on emerging environmental hazards and regional cooperation.

Resident Chris Mechenich praised the measure for upholding commitments between Stevens Point, Whiting, and the Town of Plover.

Mechenich added that mutual groundwater protection serves as vital emergency insurance for city wells."If a new chemical of concern did show up and it happened to be in one or more of our wells, we might need to ask for help from our neighbors," Mechenich said. "We might then be very glad that we protected their water supplies so that they could help us out in an emergency."

District 4 Alderperson Andrea Olsen supported the measure but questioned whether it offered enough leverage to influence conditional use permits. Beveridge clarified that for projects like the contested gas station, the amendment allows the city to classify such developments as prohibited outright in sensitive zones.

The Plan Commission approved the amendment unanimously. The amendment will head to the Common Council for final consideration.

Plan Commission, zoning ordinance amendment, groundwater, wellhead protection rules

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here